MEXICO CITY ECLIPSE 1991
A city skyline under an eclipsed sun, one bright point nearby.
Illustration, not a photograph.
Opening
On 11 July 1991, millions of people in Mexico City stopped to watch a total eclipse of the Sun. Totality there lasted more than six and a half minutes. Among the people filming the sky was Guillermo Arreguín, a Televisa employee standing south of the city, who caught a small, bright, silvery object hanging in the darkened sky. That night his clip was shown on Jacobo Zabludovsky's news programme 24 Horas.
Within days the TV journalist Jaime Maussan took up the story. Over the following months he gathered more clips from other people and presented them as several cameras filming the same metallic craft. The eclipse footage became the start of a long run of Mexican UFO broadcasts. Critics, including people who worked on the early investigation, say the object was Venus.
Timeline
11 July 1991Total solar eclipse over Mexico. In Mexico City totality begins at about 1.21pm local time and lasts about 6 minutes 38 seconds. Arreguín films a bright object for a few seconds with a VHS camcorder. He later said he had been trying to film the planets.
Same night24 Horas reports a strange phenomenon filmed by an amateur south of the city.
19 July 1991Maussan shows the eclipse footage during a marathon TV debate on UFOs, using slow motion, freeze frames, colour inversion and "solarisation" to argue the object has a three-dimensional, metallic shape.
July to September 1991Viewers send in more footage. Maussan's team collects clips from several people in Mexico City and from Puebla.
28 September 1991Maussan presents four clips side by side on national television as the same object filmed from different places. He says it hovered for seven to ten minutes.
9 March 1992A long televised debate between believers and critics shows enlargements that supporters say reveal hatches on the object. Critics say they are pixels.
1990sMaussan's count of eclipse videos rises over time, to 17 or 18 by later accounts. Mexico's long wave of televised sightings follows.
Later yearsArreguín, by now openly sceptical, says the object he filmed was Venus, distorted on video by the eclipse conditions. He and Maussan later dispute rights to the footage before Mexico's intellectual property authorities.
Key figures
Guillermo Arreguín filmed the best-known clip and has rejected the alien reading. Jaime Maussan, Mexico's best-known UFO broadcaster, built the case into a national story. Other people who filmed that day included Miguel Vallejo, who called the dot of light in his own footage "a planet", and David Alamilla. Oscar García and José Luis Martínez worked with Maussan early on, left, and later wrote critical accounts of how the case was handled.
Physical and documentary trail
The trail is the videos, the TV broadcasts that presented them, and the later written accounts by people on both sides. What is missing is a published, independent analysis that measures where each clip's object sat in the sky and compares it with the known position of Venus. Most of the debate has turned on enlarged, processed frames from low-resolution 1991 camcorder tape, which can show almost any shape.
The number of clips is also uncertain. Critics who went through Maussan's own presentations counted fewer reliable videos from Mexico City than he claimed, and some of the clips counted later were filmed far away, in Puebla.
Things you might not know
- It was a record eclipse. Its totality, nearly seven minutes at its longest, will not be beaten until 2132. Astronomers in 1991 billed it as the third longest since 1898.
- The planets came out. In the darkened midday sky Venus, by far the brightest, was visible along with Mars and Jupiter.
- The man who filmed it says Venus. The person whose clip started the story is now one of its critics.
- Japan joined in. A video from Mount Unzen in Japan, filmed in November 1991, was later added to the case because the shape looked similar.
- The footage turned into a legal fight. Arreguín accused Maussan of using his video without permission, and the dispute has gone before Mexico's copyright authorities.
Competing explanations
Venus, distorted by video. The critics' reading, and Arreguín's own. During totality Venus was the brightest planet in the darkened sky. A bright point light on an early-1990s camcorder, zoomed in, out of focus and wobbling on a handheld shot, turns into a glowing disc. Several witnesses who filmed it at the time said it looked like a star or planet.
A real object filmed by many people. Maussan's reading. He says independent cameras across the city recorded the same metallic object, hovering for minutes, with a visible structure. If the clips really show one solid object from different angles, that would rule out a planet's simple point of light.
Balloons or other objects. Proposed for some of the separate clips. A high-altitude balloon lit by the Sun can look metallic, and with so many people filming, more than one thing may have been recorded.
Later life of the case
The eclipse footage launched Maussan's long career as Mexico's leading UFO broadcaster, which later included the Campeche infrared video of 2004, the Metepec creature and the Nazca mummies.
Finding
People in Mexico City filmed a bright object during the 1991 eclipse, and Venus was shining brightly in that same darkened sky. The man who shot the most famous clip says it was Venus, and the claims of metal and hatches rest on heavily processed frames. The best explanation is Venus on camcorder tape. Supporters still point to the number of clips and the reports of hovering, and no one has published the full comparison that would settle each clip.
What still will not resolve: a frame-by-frame comparison of every clip's direction and timing with Venus's position, which has never been published.
Evidence signature
5/9 Solid
- Witnesses
- several people
- Instruments
- radar or measured data
- Paper
- press and later accounts
How well documented the case is, not whether it's true. A strong record can still have an ordinary answer, and a thin one can still be real.
You decide · MEXICO CITY ECLIPSE 1991
What do you think happened?
One vote per case, anonymous. You'll see how other readers voted once you've voted.