KUMBURGAZ
Glowing lights hang low over a dark sea beside a quiet resort.
Illustration, not a photograph.
Opening
Between 2007 and 2009, on night after night at Kumburgaz, a seaside resort on the Sea of Marmara west of Istanbul, a site guard named Yalçın Yalman filmed glowing objects over the water. He used two cameras on a tripod, one with a telescopic lens, and built up hours of footage. Close-ups show bright, structured shapes, and in some later frames people see figures sitting inside.
The footage was released in January 2008 by the Sirius UFO Space Sciences Research Center, and Turkey's national science agency, TÜBİTAK, examined it. Its report said the footage was not faked with computers or models, and that the objects could not be identified. Supporters took that as proof. The report itself was more careful, and critics have since proposed yachts with lit windows. The case is still argued over online.
Timeline
2007Yalman begins filming lights over the sea at Kumburgaz, in the Büyükçekmece district. The footage TÜBİTAK later examines dates from this year.
17 January 2008The Sirius UFO Space Sciences Research Center, run by Haktan Akdoğan, presents the footage at a press conference at the Dedeman Hotel in Istanbul, with Turkish and foreign media present. It spreads worldwide.
Early 2008A TÜBİTAK report on the footage, prepared by Professor Zeki Eker, director of the National Observatory, becomes public. On 6 February the newspaper Yeni Şafak sums it up in its headline, which translates as "It may be a UFO, but it's not an alien".
May 2009Yalman films again. He later says he noticed heads inside an object while transferring the footage to his computer.
13 June 2009At the 4th International UFO and New Age Congress in Istanbul, which also hosts Erich von Däniken, Akdoğan presents the new footage and says it shows vehicles and beings. He tells the press that TÜBİTAK found a physical object that was not a satellite, aircraft or atmospheric effect.
2010Yalman leaves Kumburgaz and settles in Ayvalık, on the Aegean coast. He keeps watching the sky on very little money and appears on Turkish television now and then, but largely drops out of view abroad. The clips live on in compilations and documentaries.
April 2010The Chilean researcher Andrés Duarte publishes an analysis proposing that the shapes are the lit side windows of boats or small yachts, filmed towards a marina east of Kumburgaz.
2024The UAP Files podcast tracks Yalman down for what it calls his first long-form interview in English, published in July. The former fighter pilot Chris Lehto had earlier tried to find him in Turkey without success.
September 2026Yalman dies after a heart attack in Mahmudiye, a village in the Ezine district of Çanakkale, and is buried there. Turkish press reports say he believed to the end that his footage showed craft from beyond Earth.
Key figures
Yalçın Yalman filmed the footage. Yeni Şafak called him the guard of a residential complex in 2008. A year later Cumhuriyet described him as a 51-year-old retired driver. He died in September 2026.
Haktan Akdoğan, of the Sirius center, released the footage, organised the congresses and spoke for the case. Critics say his summaries went further than the TÜBİTAK report did.
Professor Zeki Eker, director of TÜBİTAK's National Observatory, wrote the report, which is the only official examination of the footage.
Andrés Duarte proposed the boat explanation. The UFO researcher Roger Leir said he met Yalman and saw an object on the camera screen while it was recording.
Physical and documentary trail
The trail is the footage itself: dozens of clips, by one count close to 30 and about two and a half hours in total, plus the TÜBİTAK report, the 2008 and 2009 press coverage, and Yalman's later interview. The report says the clips are not computer animation, special effects or studio work, and that the objects match no category it checked: aircraft, helicopters, meteors, Venus, Mars, satellites, fireballs or Chinese lanterns.
The same report gives the case's biggest limit. The close-ups have no reference object in the same frame, so it could not establish where the objects were, how far away, how big, or what they were. Claims of many independent witnesses are hard to pin down: critics count only about two locals who said they saw lights over the water themselves.
Things you might not know
- "Not faked" is not "alien". TÜBİTAK called the objects UFOs in the literal sense, unidentified flying objects, and the newspaper that reported it said in its headline that this did not mean aliens.
- It was filmed from land, looking out. Kumburgaz is a resort on the Marmara shore, and the objects were filmed over the sea, where boats, marinas and the far coast all show lights at night.
- The boat theory has a match. On the Metabunk forum, a user found that the layout of a marina at Güzelce, about five miles east, fits the background of one scene when the image is flipped. The user called it suggestive, not conclusive.
- The faces came later. The famous frames with figures in the windows went through sharpening and enhancement, and critics say some widely shared versions have had features drawn in.
- Von Däniken was on the bill. The 2009 congress where the "beings" footage was shown also featured Erich von Däniken, who told reporters he had never seen a UFO himself.
Competing explanations
Structured craft, filmed repeatedly. The reading of the case's supporters. A man filming the same stretch of sky for two years got hours of footage of bright objects with visible structure, which an official science body would not identify and did not call fake. If anything here is extraordinary, the sheer number of nights is the strongest point.
Lit boat windows on the water. Duarte's explanation, backed by the marina comparison and the fact that the camera faced the sea. It fits the shapes and the colours in several clips. It has not been shown to fit every clip, and one proposed match is a cruise ship for a single scene.
Enhancement and pareidolia for the figures. The figures appear only after heavy processing of small, noisy frames, which is how faces appear in clouds and static. This explains the "aliens" without saying anything about the objects themselves.
Later life of the case
Kumburgaz remains a staple of UFO video compilations and a regular subject of debate on Metabunk and in UFO podcasts. Yalman's 2024 interview brought new interest, and supporters and sceptics have kept arguing over each clip separately. For another long-running video case that was argued over frame by frame, see the Chilean Navy video.
Finding
Yalçın Yalman filmed real objects, not computer graphics, over the Sea of Marmara on many nights, and Turkey's national observatory could not identify them. The same report said it could not judge their distance or size, and that limit matters more than anything else in the case. Lit windows on boats are the most worked-out ordinary explanation, but they have only been matched to some clips, and many people who have studied the footage still think it shows something real. The figures inside are best explained by enhancement. The objects themselves remain unidentified.
What still will not resolve: the original, unprocessed recordings with a wide shot of each scene, showing what was on the horizon when the camera zoomed in.
Evidence signature
4/9 Solid
- Witnesses
- one person, or a tradition
- Instruments
- radar or measured data
- Paper
- press and later accounts
How well documented the case is, not whether it's true. A strong record can still have an ordinary answer, and a thin one can still be real.
You decide · KUMBURGAZ
What do you think happened?
One vote per case, anonymous. You'll see how other readers voted once you've voted.