bot313 / BERMUDA TRIANGLE
00:00:00

BERMUDA TRIANGLE

Illustration Five Avenger torpedo bombers flying low over a stormy Atlantic. Illustration.

Five Avenger torpedo bombers flying low over a stormy Atlantic.
Illustration, not a period photograph.

Folder
Weird
Status
EXPLAINED Evidence 4/9
Where
25°00'00 N 071°00'00 W

Archive / Weird / BOT313-0372

WRD-19455 DEC 1945WeirdLEGEND

FLIGHT 19 AND THE LEGEND

Coords 25°00'00 N 071°00'00 W Witnesses 2Instruments 0Paper 2Evidence 4/9 SOLID

Fig. 01 Five Avenger torpedo bombers flying low over a stormy Atlantic. Illustration, not a period photograph.

Opening

The Bermuda Triangle is a stretch of the western Atlantic, roughly between Miami, Bermuda and Puerto Rico, said to swallow ships and aircraft without trace. Its most famous case is Flight 19: five US Navy Avenger torpedo bombers that vanished on a training flight on 5 December 1945, followed the same night by a flying boat sent to search for them.

The idea grew in magazines through the 1950s, the name took hold in 1964, and two bestsellers in 1974 made it a global legend. Investigators who went back to the original records found that the mystery mostly came from how the stories were retold.

Timeline

31 January 1880The Royal Navy training ship HMS Atalanta sails from Bermuda and vanishes, presumed lost in a storm. Much later it is added to the Triangle's list.

March 1918The US Navy collier USS Cyclops, loaded with manganese ore, disappears with 306 people on board after leaving Barbados for Baltimore. It's the largest single loss of life in US naval history not involving combat.

31 January 1921The five-masted schooner Carroll A. Deering is found aground and abandoned on Diamond Shoals, North Carolina. An FBI inquiry rules out piracy and rum-runners but never explains what happened to the crew.

5 December 1945Flight 19, five TBM Avengers from Naval Air Station Fort Lauderdale, led by Lieutenant Charles Taylor, loses its way on a training flight. Taylor believes his compasses have failed and that the flight is over the Florida Keys. The planes fly on until they run out of fuel. All 14 men are lost.

The same nightA PBM Mariner flying boat sent to search disappears with its 13 crew. A passing tanker reports flames on the sea at about the time it would have been in the area. Mariners were known for fuel vapour leaks and were nicknamed "flying gas tanks."

30 January 1948The airliner Star Tiger disappears on a flight from the Azores to Bermuda. On 17 January 1949 its sister ship, Star Ariel, vanishes between Bermuda and Jamaica. Both were flying near the limits of their range.

28 December 1948A Douglas DC-3 airliner disappears between San Juan and Miami with 32 people aboard. No trace is found.

17 September 1950An Associated Press article by Edward Van Winkle Jones is the first to suggest that something unusual is happening to ships and planes near Bermuda.

October 1952George X. Sand's article "Sea Mystery at Our Back Door" in Fate magazine first marks out a triangle.

February 1964Writer Vincent Gaddis uses the phrase "the deadly Bermuda Triangle" in Argosy magazine.

1974Charles Berlitz's The Bermuda Triangle becomes an international bestseller, linking the losses to Atlantis and other forces. Richard Winer's The Devil's Triangle comes out the same year.

1975Librarian Larry Kusche publishes The Bermuda Triangle Mystery: Solved, after checking the original records of dozens of cases, and calls the legend "a manufactured mystery."

1976A NOVA and Horizon documentary concludes that ships and planes behave in the Triangle the same way they behave everywhere else.

Key figures

Lieutenant Charles Taylor led Flight 19. The Navy's investigation first blamed him, then changed the finding to "causes or reasons unknown" after his family appealed.

Edward Van Winkle Jones and George X. Sand laid the groundwork. Vincent Gaddis is usually credited with naming the Triangle.

Charles Berlitz turned it into a global phenomenon.

Larry Kusche, a librarian at Arizona State University, checked the sources and found many cases misreported, exaggerated or invented. Some ships said to have vanished in calm seas were lost in storms, and some losses happened nowhere near the Triangle.

Physical and documentary trail

What exists: the Navy's Flight 19 investigation, radio transcripts from the flight, US Coast Guard records, accident inquiries into the lost airliners, and insurance records. The Coast Guard and Lloyd's of London have both said the area is not unusually dangerous given its heavy traffic, and Lloyd's does not charge higher premiums to cross it. The US National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration puts most losses down to hurricanes, the fast-changing weather of the Gulf Stream, and shallow waters around the islands.

What is missing, in the famous cases, is the wreckage itself. The Cyclops, Flight 19 and the two Star airliners have never been found.

Things you might not know

  • Gaddis turned it into a book. He expanded his 1964 article into Invisible Horizons: True Mysteries of the Sea, published in 1965.
  • It has another name. The area has also been called "the Devil's Triangle".
  • There is no agreed map. Gaddis put its corners at Miami, San Juan in Puerto Rico and Bermuda, but other writers drew it differently, from about 1.3 to 3.9 million square kilometres, so which losses count depends on who is counting.
  • Many of the cases were not in it. Larry Kusche found that a large share of the incidents blamed on the Triangle actually happened well outside it.
  • A "second crash" was seaweed. After two Air Force tankers collided west of Bermuda in 1963, a supposed second crash site turned out, Kusche found, to be seaweed and driftwood tangled around an old buoy.
  • A "ghost ship" had simply drifted. The yacht Connemara IV, found empty south of Bermuda in 1955, had dragged its moorings in the tail of Hurricane Janet and floated out to sea.

Competing explanations

Unknown forces. Theories include magnetic anomalies, Atlantis, rogue waves, methane eruptions and UFOs. None is supported by evidence that the area has more losses than expected. Methane bubbles can sink a model ship in a laboratory, but the US Geological Survey reports no large releases in the area for 15,000 years, and no unusual magnetic anomalies have been found.

A busy, stormy sea and good storytelling. The area has heavy shipping and air traffic, strong currents including the Gulf Stream, which can carry wreckage away fast, sudden storms, and shallow reefs. Most official inquiries point to weather and human error. Flight 19 is explained by navigation error, bad weather and fuel exhaustion.

Later life of the case

The Triangle remains one of the best-known mysteries in the world and a staple of documentaries. The documentary record hasn't changed since Kusche. For the Great Lakes' version of the same idea, see the Lake Michigan Triangle, and for the most famous single loss, Flight 19.

Finding

Not a mystery zone. The Triangle is a busy, weather-prone stretch of ocean with an ordinary loss rate, turned into a legend by writers who didn't check the records. Flight 19 was a tragedy of navigation and weather. The Cyclops is a real open case, as some losses at sea always are.

What still will not resolve: what happened to the Cyclops, which went down with no distress call and has never been found.

Evidence signature

4/9 Solid

Witnesses
several people
Instruments
nothing on record
Paper
official records at the time

How well documented the case is, not whether it's true. A strong record can still have an ordinary answer, and a thin one can still be real.

You decide · BERMUDA TRIANGLE

What do you think happened?

One vote per case, anonymous. You'll see how other readers voted once you've voted.

Next file

See also

← BACK ← Weird ← HOME